Ron DeSantis and Republicans’ Mar-a-Lago Playbook

Republican politicians weighing methods to react to the F.B.I.’s search of Mar-a-Lago final week had a number of choices. Boiled down, they had been:

1. Instantly denounce it as a “witch hunt” and threaten to research and even defund the bureau, whereas calling for Lawyer Basic Merrick Garland’s impeachment.

2. Problem a cautious, place-holder assertion expressing confidence within the course of whereas sounding a notice of concern concerning the potential for Justice Division overreach. Say little that might change into embarrassing ought to extra info emerge that painting the previous president’s conduct in a damaging mild.

3. Criticize Trump as having jeopardized the nationwide safety of the US. Name on him to launch the search warrant and clarify what brokers may need been searching for, and why he had not returned the paperwork they had been searching for.

4. Await extra info earlier than commenting in any respect.

To defend or to not defend?

The political dilemma was notably acute for Republicans who aspire to run for president in 2024 — requiring a high-wire act worthy of the Flying Wallendas.

Enter Ron DeSantis, the governor of Florida, who’s broadly seen as Trump’s most critical potential rival in a Republican major race. The political world watches DeSantis’s each transfer these days, and plenty of awaited his response to the search with bated breath.

Generally, mischief ensues.

In a intelligent however dishonest little bit of on-line skulduggery, somebody spliced collectively two separate movies to make it appear as if DeSantis had defended the F.B.I. The manipulated video, which circulated broadly on social media, purports to indicate DeSantis tangling with Sean Hannity over the Fox Information host’s use of the phrase “raid” to explain the F.B.I.’s actions.

“It’s not a raid,” DeSantis says within the edited video, including, “they had been serving legitimate course of in accordance with the legal guidelines and Structure of the US.”

It could have been an explosive second — the primary actual fireworks of the shadow 2024 presidential major.

However it by no means occurred.

In actuality, DeSantis had been defending a 2020 search by legislation enforcement officers of the house of Rebekah Jones, a former information specialist for the state of Florida who had claimed that the DeSantis administration was manipulating details about the coronavirus pandemic.

Hannity, for one, called the video “FAKE NEWS” and demanded that Twitter take away it.

What DeSantis really mentioned was this tweet:

“The raid of MAL is one other escalation within the weaponization of federal businesses in opposition to the Regime’s political opponents, whereas individuals like Hunter Biden get handled with child gloves,” DeSantis wrote. “Now the Regime is getting one other 87k IRS brokers to wield in opposition to its adversaries? Banana Republic.”

Observe what was lacking right here: any protection of Trump’s conduct. DeSantis made related remarks at a rally on Sunday for Kari Lake and Blake Masters, the Republican nominees for governor and Senate in Arizona — criticizing the Justice Division and elevating examples of what he characterised as F.B.I. misconduct, whereas remaining silent on the previous president’s alleged mishandling of categorized paperwork.

The DeSantis dance

David Jolly, a former Republican member of Congress from Florida, mentioned the “dance” between DeSantis and Trump was quietly consuming each camps behind the scenes.

Trump has periodically famous — precisely — that he stays the most well-liked Republican in hypothetical 2024 major matchups, with DeSantis a distant second. However the two have but to spar in earnest.

As a substitute, they’ve been circling one another like cage fighters prowling the ring earlier than a match.

Allies of DeSantis have spun up “Prepared for Ron,” a brilliant PAC backing the Florida governor’s potential candidacy — at the same time as he insists that he’s centered on his re-election in Florida and that he has no connection to the trouble. (Ed Rollins, a longtime Republican operative who’s main the tremendous PAC, didn’t reply to a request for remark.)

But DeSantis has additionally courted Trump’s donors, and infrequently criticized the previous president’s dealing with of the pandemic. Trump allies have warily eyed his maneuvering, whereas speaking down DeSantis to reporters as an overrated political expertise.

In response to Jolly, “the neatest factor Trump may do is declare proper now.”

That, he mentioned, may very well be “the catalyzing second that squeezes all people else” out of the Republican discipline by forcing potential contenders like DeSantis to both defend Trump extra aggressively or distance themselves from the previous president’s authorized woes.

But when Trump cleared the decks to gear up for a 3rd presidential bid by stoking anti-government stress over his authorized difficulties, Jolly added, he can be creating “probably the most harmful moments I feel our nation may face.”

The silent remedy

Some may say the politically savvy plan of action for Republicans can be to decide on the fourth choice from the menu above: Say nothing.

That’s what Charlie Dent, a former member of Congress from Pennsylvania, instructed his fellow Republicans must have accomplished because the information emerged that federal brokers had searched Trump’s house.

“At a time like this, my recommendation to G.O.P. members can be to indicate restraint and be circumspect of their public feedback,” mentioned Dent, who retired in 2018 relatively than face re-election after changing into one of many extra dependable critics of Trump’s conduct as president.

“With Trump,” Dent added, “there’s all the time extra to the story — and it’s often not superb.”

Because the week wore on, that recommendation appeared more and more sound.

Information retailers, together with this one, reported that the F.B.I. was seeking to retrieve extremely categorized paperwork that Trump or one in all his aides had taken from the White Home and stashed on the former president’s personal membership and residence in West Palm Seashore.

A few of the paperwork, The Washington Put up reported, pertained to nuclear weapons — among the many most delicate supplies within the federal authorities’s possession.

But staying silent shouldn’t be what many Republicans did. Let’s briefly assessment what occurred:

• Ronna McDaniel, the chairwoman of the Republican Nationwide Committee, wrote an opinion essay for Fox Information that described the search as “a part of a sample of bureaucratic abuse in opposition to Trump.”

• Consultant Kevin McCarthy of California, the highest-ranking Republican within the Home, issued a transparent menace to the Justice Division, saying that Republicans deliberate to “conduct rapid oversight” of the company. “Lawyer Basic Garland, protect your paperwork and clear your calendar,” McCarthy mentioned.

• Consultant Elise Stefanik of New York, the third-ranking Republican within the Home, said the F.B.I. had dedicated an “abuse of energy on the highest ranges.”

• Consultant Jim Jordan, a key Trump ally, called on Garland and Christopher Wray, the F.B.I.’s Trump-appointed director, to testify concerning the search earlier than the Home Judiciary Committee.

• Senator Mitch McConnell, the highest Republican within the Senate, declined to touch upon the search throughout a visit to go to flood-ravaged communities in his native Kentucky.

• Consultant Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia known as on Congress to “defund the F.B.I.”

In the previous couple of days, nonetheless, as contemporary info has dribbled out about why the Justice Division deemed it essential to pressure its means into Mar-a-Lago, most elected Republicans have settled on a posture much like DeSantis’s: ripping the F.B.I. and Justice Division as having overreached, whereas declining to again Trump outright.

In a revealing look on NBC’s “Meet the Press,” Senator Mike Rounds, Republican of South Dakota, urged the division to launch extra details about the “justification for this raid.”

However he shortly veered towards extra favorable political terrain.

“Proper now, with the 2022 midterms developing,” Rounds mentioned, “we’d a lot desire to give attention to what the insurance policies are proper now which can be hurting our economic system.”

What to learn

• Authorized pressures on Donald Trump and his shut allies have intensified additional: Prosecutors knowledgeable Rudolph Giuliani, his former private lawyer, that he was a goal of a wide-ranging prison investigation into election interference in Georgia.

• Republican lawmakers in Wisconsin are pushing intensely to take larger management over the state’s voting infrastructure. However whether or not that occurs may depend upon two enormous elections, one in November and one in April, Reid Epstein writes.

• The Republicans’ Senate marketing campaign committee has reduce its tv advert reservations in three important battleground states for the autumn, a possible signal of economic troubles, Shane Goldmacher stories.

• With Liz Cheney dealing with a near-certain defeat tomorrow in her Home major, it’s the doubtless finish of the Cheney household’s two-generation dynasty in Wyoming, in addition to the passing of a much less tribal and extra clubby and substance-oriented model of politics. Jonathan Martin has the story.

— Blake

Is there something you assume we’re lacking? Something you wish to see extra of? We’d love to listen to from you. E-mail us at onpolitics@nytimes.com.