Triple-I Blog | California Takes Top Spot on ATRA’s “Hellholes” List; Pennsylvania Falls to No. 4

Feb 3, 2022

[ad_1]

California has reclaimed its prime spot on the “Judicial Hellholes” checklist maintained by the American Tort Reform Affiliation (ATRA).

“California’s appellate courts are the primary to carry e-commerce corporations strictly responsible for merchandise bought on their websites,” ATRA writes in its 2021-2022 report. “Baseless Prop-65 lawsuits thrive in courts, and the amount of litigation continues to skyrocket.”

The report additionally factors to what it calls “frivolous” Personal Legal professional Normal Act (PAGA) and People with Incapacity Act (ADA) lawsuits and says the state’s Lemon Legislation “offers windfalls for plaintiffs’ legal professionals.”

New York State is an in depth quantity two, ATRA says, “as the 2 jurisdictions battle it out for essentially the most ‘no-injury’ class motion lawsuits and essentially the most claims beneath the ADA.” It provides that New York “is a most well-liked jurisdiction for asbestos litigation and, like California, the legislature ignores the necessity for reform and continues to push a liability-expanding agenda.”

Georgia has risen to quantity three on the premise of what ATRA calls the “important deterioration” of its civil justice system.

“The Georgia Supreme Courtroom eradicated apportionment of fault in sure instances and expanded unhealthy religion legal responsibility for insurers,” ATRA says. “It additionally adopted an expansive view of jurisdiction of its courts over out-of-state companies. Nuclear verdicts are bogging down enterprise, and third-party litigation financing is enjoying an growing position in litigation.”

Pennsylvania fell from primary to quantity 4, however ATRA says this “was on no account a mirrored image of progress or enhancements made within the state, however moderately indicative of the variety of points plaguing different jurisdictions.”

ATRA is a Washington, D.C.-based group fashioned in 1986 and devoted to tort and legal responsibility reform. It has revealed the Judicial Hellholes report since 2002. 

[ad_2]